The Pope has called on infertile couples to shun artificial procreation, saying such methods are a form of arrogance – Associated Press
It’s disappointing to learn that someone of stature and respect within the Catholic church would call methods to treat infertility as arrogant. Does that mean that my desire to have children is merely an arrogant need?
I’m grateful that I’m not Catholic. I respect that the Catholic church have their own traditions that impact how followers perceive birth control and procreation. I understand that embryos created through IVF treatment is very much a “child” (at the point of conception.) and that destroying them goes against the church. After my miscarriage, I’ve realized that I value conception and what that means from a pro-life perspective (*but not necessarily when it involves incest/rape etc.)
But it’s disappointing that someone who supposedly loves God and believes in procreation cannot understand how fertility treatment has built families and provided hope for so many who wouldn’t otherwise be able to have children.
Speaking at a conference on infertility in Rome, the Pope said artificial methods of getting pregnant were arrogance, insisting that sex between a husband and wife was the only acceptable way of conceiving.
Matrimony was the “only place worthy of the call to existence of a new human being”, he told scientists and fertility experts. Read More
I’d like to assure the Pope that my husband and I have had plenty of sex the last four-years. Let me also assure him that it hasn’t been easy to conceive. Despite a natural pregnancy in 2010 and an ectopic (IVF) pregnancy last year, I’ve yet to see a child in our lives. If matrimony is the “only place worth of the call to existence of a new human being,” then I’d like the Pope to realized that it hasn’t happened for us despite years of heartache and trying.
Dear Pope Benedict, you’re out of touch. One in six couples have some form of infertility. I’m sure that in those statistics, there are plenty of Catholic couples struggling with the pain of not being able to have children naturally. Who are you to judge? A man of God without wife and child? Who are you to assume that such methods – IVF, IUI, ART – are arrogant? Have you felt the heartache of many men and women who have faced life with infertility, multiple miscarriages and stillbirths? Do you know what couples have had to do to have children?
There was the monthly trying, the temperature tracking, the ovulation tracking, the cervical fluid gathering and the regular “pee-on-a” stick – and yet, there have been no children. Yep, that was my matrimonial intercourse. Why don’t you try having sex regularly when you’re not in the mood but you know you need to so that you can have a baby? Oh wait, you can’t.
I didn’t ask for this “disease.” If a cancer patient can ask for healing and seek treatment from hospitals, why can’t I? Is my disease so special that I shouldn’t be allowed to seek alternate treatment? Dear Pope, if you had a wife and you felt her pain daily, you would understand a bit of what I’m saying now.
This is why people hate “religion.” You regiment what you believe (you think) life should be but not realize that real life is not the Catholic Church version.
He told the science and fertility experts in his audience to resist “the fascination of the technology of artificial fertility. Benedict cautioned the experts against “easy income, or even worse, the arrogance of taking the place of the Creator,” an attitude he indicated underlies the field of artificial procreation. – Read More
Please understand that I’m not angry with you. I do realize that you are Catholic and your beliefs mark your faith and doctrine. Nevertheless, I think it’s not your place to talk about birth, babies and procreation when you have absolutely no experience in the process (or the heartache.) Keep the church out of my sex life or my procreation processes. You have no business to tell me what I can or cannot do to have a baby.
I believe that God created the world. I also believe that God provided us with expertise and resources that allows men and women around the world to seek the help they need.
Infertility is painful. Calling possible infertility solutions as “arrogant” only devalue the pain that so many of us are already feeling.
Dear Pope, please don’t assume that infertility is not serious or that it carries less weight than diseases like HIV or cancer or depression. We feel real pain, depression, hopelessness and despair with each failure to get pregnant. It is like ANY other disease that needs medical intervention.
You represent the Catholic Church. Please do so with humility and understanding of the men and women who look up to you for your leadership. Your words hurt so many. Including myself.
Don’t stay out of touch. Be informed about infertility. And keep your opinions (and of the church) to yourself.
Like this:
One blogger likes this post.